Abstract

Organisations can explain a change clearly, train people to work differently and still find familiar practices continuing. This article examines why knowledge and intention may be insufficient to change behaviour. Drawing on behavioural research and an illustrative system implementation, it considers the influence of habits, competing demands and organisational conditions. It also distinguishes understanding a process from being able to perform it in practice. For transformation leaders, the implication is to establish what is influencing the behaviour before deciding whether further communication or training is the appropriate response. That requires attention to the work itself and the decisions surrounding it.

Keywords

organisational change; behaviour change; knowing–doing gap; system adoption; leadership accountability; transformation

When the message has landed and the behaviour hasn’t changed

I’ve spent a large part of my career trying to understand why people behave the way they do, particularly when what they do seems to be completely at odds with what they know.

A leader can genuinely understand that they need to listen more and still dominate the next meeting. An organisation can introduce a new system, explain why it matters and train everyone to use it, then discover that people are still managing their work in spreadsheets.

One familiar response is to explain again. We communicate more, provide more information, run another training session or remind people why the change matters. There seems to be an assumption buried somewhere in this response that if people know better, they should do better.

Sometimes further explanation is exactly what is needed. But when people already understand the expectation, we need to become curious about what happens between understanding it and acting on it. Otherwise, we can keep investing in an intervention that addresses only part of the problem.

Knowledge, intention and action are different things

Knowing what to do, intending to do it and actually doing it are related, but they are different. Someone may understand a process without agreeing that it is useful. They may agree with it and intend to follow it, yet find it difficult to use when other demands compete for their attention.

Research helps explain why stronger intentions do not necessarily produce an equivalent change in action. Webb and Sheeran (2006) examined 47 experimental tests and found that changes in intention were accompanied, on average, by smaller changes in behaviour. Their review concerns behaviour across studied settings; it does not establish an organisational transformation success rate. It does, however, give us a reason to examine what happens beyond securing agreement.

In a workplace, that distinction matters because a positive response to a presentation or training session tells us something about that occasion. It leaves open the question of what the person will encounter when they return to their work.

An organisation can keep making the old approach useful

Consider a hypothetical organisation introducing a project management system to improve visibility across the business. People receive training and understand that projects should now be managed through the system. Months later, work is still being coordinated through spreadsheets, emails and Teams messages.

It is tempting to describe this as resistance or a communication failure. I would first want to understand what people are doing, what they know and what the work requires of them.

Perhaps the spreadsheet is quicker for a task they perform repeatedly. Perhaps their manager still asks for a separate report, so maintaining the new system creates an additional reporting obligation. Perhaps another function cannot access the information it needs, leaving the team to keep a parallel record.

Those possibilities lead to different questions. A usability problem, a conflicting management expectation and a cross-functional dependency may look similar in a usage report. They do not necessarily call for the same response.

The organisation may have announced one way of working while continuing to rely on another. In that setting, a reminder to use the system leaves the competing expectations unresolved. Someone still has to decide which information is required, where it belongs and how managers will use it.

This example is illustrative rather than a reported client case. The point is that the explanation for a behaviour cannot be read directly from the fact that it has continued.

Knowing the process does not establish practical capability

If someone can explain the new process accurately, I have learned something useful. I have not yet established that they can carry it out under the conditions in which they work.

They may understand the standard workflow but be unsure what to do when information is missing or an exception occurs. They may have completed an exercise successfully during training, with guidance available, and struggle when several demands arrive together.

The COM-B model provides a useful way of keeping this broader picture in view. Michie, van Stralen and West (2011) describe behaviour in terms of capability, opportunity and motivation. Capability includes relevant knowledge and skills; opportunity concerns the surrounding physical and social conditions; motivation includes deliberate and more automatic processes.

For organisational practice, I take from this the importance of investigating more than understanding alone. A person’s explanation, their performance of the task and the conditions around that performance provide different kinds of evidence. The model offers a way to organise inquiry; it does not establish the cause of a particular adoption problem without examining the situation.

Familiar work does not disappear when a new process is announced

Established routines also deserve attention. Someone who has managed a task in the same way for years may be able to complete familiar steps with little conscious effort. A replacement process may require sustained attention, especially while it is unfamiliar.

Wood and Neal (2007) describe habits as learned associations between responses and recurring features of their context. Their account helps explain how familiar situations can continue to cue established behaviour even when a person has a different intention.

Applying that idea to our hypothetical organisation, the usual request from a manager, the weekly reporting meeting or the familiar spreadsheet may remain part of the working context. Announcing a new process does not, by itself, establish that those influences have changed.

Habit is one possible explanation. A spreadsheet may also be retained deliberately because it serves a requirement the new system does not meet. That distinction matters: assuming everything is habit can obscure a legitimate operational problem just as easily as assuming everything is resistance.

Leadership expectations are part of the conditions

The same inquiry needs to include what leaders do. If managers continue to ask for information in the previous format, teams have to decide how to satisfy that request alongside the new requirement. If deadlines allow no time to learn an unfamiliar task, the expectation to adopt it competes with the expectation to deliver immediately.

These are questions about priorities, capacity and accountability. A programme team may identify the difficulty without having the authority to resolve it. Removing a duplicate reporting requirement, for example, may depend on a business leader agreeing to change how they receive information and make decisions.

My interpretation is that understanding adoption requires examining those arrangements alongside individual behaviour. People still have responsibilities, including raising difficulties and engaging with the change. Leaders have responsibilities for the expectations and decisions that make the required practice workable.

Observe the work before choosing the response

Communication and education remain important. If people do not understand an expectation, or lack the skills to carry it out, addressing that gap may be necessary. The mistake is treating unchanged behaviour as sufficient evidence that the message has failed.

Before commissioning another intervention, I would want to understand where the intended way of working and the actual work part company. What happens at that point? Which requirements compete? What function is the existing approach serving? And who can change the conditions that matter?

These questions begin an inquiry rather than supply a universal diagnostic. A workable response depends on the interaction between the task, the people involved and the wider organisation. Changing one condition can also create consequences elsewhere, which is why selecting an intervention requires experienced judgement.

The next time a team continues to work in a way the organisation expected to change, establish what people understand and what they can do. Then look closely at the circumstances in which the work occurs. If they already know, what else is going on? That is usually where I want to start.

References

Michie, S., van Stralen, M. M. and West, R. (2011). The behaviour change wheel: A new method for characterising and designing behaviour change interventions. Implementation Science, 6, article 42. https://doi.org/10.1186/1748-5908-6-42

Webb, T. L. and Sheeran, P. (2006). Does changing behavioral intentions engender behavior change? A meta-analysis of the experimental evidence. Psychological Bulletin, 132(2), 249–268. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.132.2.249

Wood, W. and Neal, D. T. (2007). A new look at habits and the habit-goal interface. Psychological Review, 114(4), 843–863. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.114.4.843

Publication and disclosure notes

Adapted from Dr Liz Wilson’s article “Why Knowing What to Do Doesn’t Mean We’ll Do It”, first published on thedrliz.com: https://thedrliz.com/why-knowing-what-to-do-doesnt-mean-well-do-it/

The project management system example is hypothetical. Its possible explanations illustrate practitioner reasoning and are not reported findings from a client engagement.

The author is Founder & Editor of Transformation Expert Insights and works professionally in behavioural and organisational transformation.

AI assistance: OpenAI ChatGPT assisted with adapting the original article, restructuring the argument, drafting wording and identifying and checking references. The author is responsible for the published content.

About the author

Dr Liz Wilson

Founder & Editor, Transformation Expert Insights

Dr Liz Wilson is a Behavioural Transformation Practitioner, behavioural scientist, author and keynote speaker. Her work connects behavioural science with the practical demands of organisational transformation, including leadership, governance, systems and everyday ways of working. She is interested in why people and organisations continue familiar practices despite understanding the case for change, and how the conditions surrounding work influence what becomes possible. She is Founder & Editor of Transformation Expert Insights, a professional publication bringing together research, commentary and practitioner perspectives on business and enterprise transformation.

Professional website: https://thedrliz.com/

Back to top ↑Contact the editor