Abstract
Organisations frequently respond to performance, accountability and behavioural problems by focusing on the individuals involved. Yet people make decisions and adapt their behaviour within environments shaped by leadership, incentives, processes, systems and social expectations. Drawing on experience across organisational development, inclusion and enterprise transformation, this article examines how organisational conditions influence what people feel able, expected and rewarded to do. It considers why well intended behavioural interventions can fail when the surrounding environment remains unchanged, and argues that effective transformation requires leaders to examine the relationship between individual responsibility and the conditions that shape everyday behaviour.
organisational culture; behavioural change; organisational transformation; employee behaviour; leadership accountability; psychological safety
Why do people behave differently in different organisational environments?
My career began in organisational development and change, and later expanded into transformation. I then spent several years focused specifically on inclusion, before returning to broader enterprise transformation. Across those different areas of work, I have kept coming back to the relationship between people and the environments around them, and how easily we underestimate it when trying to understand why something is happening in an organisation.
It’s common to start with the person. If someone doesn’t speak up, we wonder whether they lack confidence. If someone isn’t performing, we question their capability or motivation. If a team isn’t collaborating, we look at personalities. If people aren’t adopting a new way of working, we decide they are resistant to change.
Sometimes those explanations will be right. People bring their own histories, personalities, capabilities and preferences into every environment they enter. But they are also responding to what happens around them, including things that may be much less visible to the person assessing their behaviour.
Most of us have experienced this ourselves. We can be confident in one room and hesitant in another. We can contribute freely in one team and barely speak in another. We might be comfortable challenging an idea with one leader, while spending the entire conversation with another deciding whether saying what we actually think is worth the trouble it could create.
We haven’t necessarily become a different person between those situations. We have learned something about the people and circumstances around us, and we are taking that into account.
Perhaps one leader listens before responding, while another becomes defensive. Perhaps we have watched someone be embarrassed for asking a question, or seen a colleague raise a legitimate concern only to have it quietly held against them afterwards. Perhaps everyone else appears to agree, and we are trying to work out whether we have missed something or whether nobody else wants to be the first to disagree either.
Research on employee voice and silence supports the importance of these considerations. Morrison (2023) examines how employees’ decisions to raise concerns or withhold information are influenced by interpersonal and organisational conditions, including their expectations about the consequences of speaking up.
When we look only at the individual, we can miss all of that.
We might recommend confidence coaching to someone who has already worked out, quite accurately, that speaking openly carries a cost.
For leaders responsible for organisational change, that distinction matters. If we misunderstand why people are behaving as they do, we risk investing in interventions that leave the underlying problem untouched.
What inclusion helped me examine more closely
During my research on the 8-Inclusion Needs of All People (Wilson, 2023), I spent considerable time exploring what people actually need to experience to participate fully.
That distinction mattered because inclusion can become quite abstract. An organisation can say it values inclusion, its leaders can sincerely believe they are inclusive, and its workforce can include people with many different backgrounds and experiences. Those things still don’t tell us enough about what it is like for a particular person trying to participate there.
I wanted to understand the conditions around that participation. Do people have access to what they need? Can they express what they think, and are they heard when they do? Can they influence decisions that affect them? Are differences in circumstances recognised, or are people expected to find their own way around arrangements that were designed with someone else in mind?
Feeling that we belong is part of that experience, but it cannot tell us everything.
We might feel accepted by our colleagues while being unable to access an opportunity, contribute to a decision or raise something that matters to us. We might also know that our acceptance depends on avoiding certain subjects or keeping parts of ourselves out of view.
That work gave me a more detailed understanding of how differently people can experience the same organisation. Returning to enterprise transformation, those questions remain relevant to how I examine processes, systems, leadership and the everyday experience of getting work done.
It also reinforced something I believe is particularly important in transformation: we cannot assume that because a process, policy or system exists, everyone experiences it in the same way or has the same opportunity to use it effectively.
What are we teaching people to do?
I often see organisations respond to a problem by trying to change people’s behaviour before examining what might be encouraging it.
A team has a problem with accountability, so we talk about taking greater ownership. Employees aren’t speaking up, so we run psychological safety training. Leaders aren’t collaborating, so we put them through a leadership programme. People aren’t following a process, so we retrain them.
Any of those interventions might be useful. There are absolutely times when someone needs new knowledge, different skills or support to change their behaviour. But I also want to understand what happens when they try to do what we are asking.
If we tell people to take ownership but require three levels of approval before they can make a decision, waiting for permission becomes understandable. If we ask leaders to collaborate but measure their success almost entirely through their own function’s performance, we have given them competing expectations. And if we train people to follow a process while allowing senior leaders to bypass it whenever it becomes inconvenient, people will draw their own conclusions about how seriously to take it.
This is where we can become unfairly frustrated with people. We see what they are doing, but don’t give the same attention to the arrangements, consequences and examples that make their behaviour sensible.
People learn how an organisation works by experiencing it. They notice when a policy says one thing and their manager expects another. They notice when everyone talks about wellbeing but the person who works until midnight is praised for their commitment. They notice when challenging the status quo is encouraged, until the status quo happens to belong to somebody powerful.
Over time, those experiences influence what people are prepared to do.
Research on psychological safety offers one useful explanation for part of this relationship. Edmondson (1999) found an association between team psychological safety and learning behaviour in a study of 51 work teams. The findings help explain why the interpersonal conditions within teams can matter for behaviours such as asking questions, discussing mistakes and seeking feedback.
Of course, psychological safety is only one aspect of the organisational environment. People also respond to decision rights, performance measures, workload, access to information and the practical consequences of following established processes.
We learn what produces a reward, what creates friction, what carries risk and what other people appear to be getting away with. Some responses become so familiar that we barely think about them anymore.
For me, that is one of the more useful ways to examine culture. I want to understand what happens in meetings, who gets listened to, how disagreements are handled and what happens when a deadline comes into conflict with a stated organisational value. I am interested in which problems get resolved quickly and which remain in place for years, despite everyone apparently knowing about them.
Those everyday experiences tell us a great deal about what people have learned to expect.
Understanding the environment still leaves room for responsibility
None of this means people have no agency, or that every behaviour can be explained away by the system. People make choices, and some of those choices need to be challenged. Leaders are responsible for how they treat others. Capability gaps need to be addressed. Harmful conduct does not become acceptable because we understand something about the circumstances around it.
Understanding context helps us make a better judgement about what needs to change and who can change it.
If ten different people enter the same environment and eventually begin behaving in remarkably similar ways, I become very interested in the environment. If capable people repeatedly make decisions that produce poor outcomes, I want to understand the conditions in which those decisions make sense. If we keep replacing people and encountering the same problems, I want to know what each new person is being asked to work within.
That means looking closely at what happens before and after the behaviour that concerns us. What information was available? What authority did the person have? What other expectations were they trying to meet? What did they believe would happen if they took a different approach?
We may still conclude that the individual needs to change. We may also discover that we have made the behaviour we want unnecessarily difficult, while making another behaviour easier, safer or more rewarding.
The distinction becomes particularly important when organisations are undergoing transformation, because people are often being asked to adopt new behaviours while continuing to operate within arrangements designed for the old way of working.
What this means for leaders managing organisational change
When organisations invest in transformation, considerable attention is often given to defining what needs to change. New processes are designed, responsibilities are allocated, systems are introduced and expectations are communicated.
Yet the practical question remains: what will people experience when they attempt to work differently?
A leader may be told to make decisions more quickly but still lack the authority to approve them. A team may be expected to collaborate across functions while continuing to work towards conflicting priorities. Employees may be asked to identify improvement opportunities while having little confidence that their suggestions will be considered.
These are not necessarily problems that can be resolved through better communication or additional training.
They require leaders to examine whether the organisation’s operating conditions support the behaviours it expects.
I think there are several questions worth asking before deciding that a behavioural problem requires a behavioural intervention.
What happens when someone attempts the behaviour we want? What makes that behaviour easier or harder? What consequences follow? Are our processes, systems, leadership practices and performance measures reinforcing the same expectations? And are people receiving consistent signals about what actually matters?
The answers may reveal that the organisation needs to change something about how work is structured, how decisions are made, how performance is assessed or how leaders respond.
This also creates an opportunity to evaluate transformation more meaningfully. Rather than relying exclusively on whether people attended training, understood a communication or reported confidence in a new approach, we can examine whether the conditions have changed and whether the intended behaviours are becoming part of everyday work.
For example, if greater accountability is the objective, we can examine whether decision authority has become clearer, whether unnecessary approvals have been reduced and whether decisions are being made and acted upon at the appropriate level.
If greater collaboration is the objective, we can examine how competing priorities are resolved, whether information moves effectively between teams and whether shared outcomes influence decisions.
Those measures will not explain every individual choice, but they can help establish whether the organisation is making its expectations more achievable.
Before asking people to change
Looking across my career, I see these questions running through the different parts of my work. Organisational development, change, inclusion and enterprise transformation each give me ways to examine how people experience the organisations they are part of, and what enables or gets in the way of their contribution.
So when I see behaviour that doesn’t seem to make sense, I try to resist settling too quickly on an explanation about the person. I want to understand what they are responding to, including what we may have unintentionally taught them.
For organisations, this requires a willingness to examine the consequences of their own decisions and arrangements, including those that have become so familiar they are rarely questioned.
People don’t behave in a vacuum. If we want them to behave differently, we need to be willing to examine the environment we are asking them to do it in.
References
Edmondson, A. (1999). Psychological safety and learning behavior in work teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350–383. https://doi.org/10.2307/2666999
Morrison, E. W. (2023). Employee voice and silence: Taking stock a decade later. Annual Review of Organizational Psychology and Organizational Behavior, 10, 79–107. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-orgpsych-120920-054654
Wilson, L. A. (2023). The 8-Inclusion Needs of All People: A proposed framework to address intersectionality in efforts to prevent discrimination. International Journal of Social Science Research and Review, 6(2), 296–314. https://doi.org/10.47814/ijssrr.v6i2.937
Publication and disclosure notes
An earlier version of this article was published on Medium under the same title. This version has been adapted and expanded for Transformation Expert Insights.
The organisational examples are illustrative and are not reported client cases or measurements of intervention effectiveness.
The author is Founder & Editor of Transformation Expert Insights and works professionally in behavioural and organisational transformation.
AI assistance: OpenAI ChatGPT assisted with editorial restructuring, research identification, drafting additional passages and aligning the article with publication guidelines. The author is responsible for reviewing and approving the final content and references.