Abstract

Appointing a Transformation Director establishes leadership for a programme, but leaves important questions about executive ownership unresolved. This article examines the distinction between recognising a business problem, sponsoring a programme and taking responsibility for the decisions and operational changes it requires. Drawing on organisational readiness theory and research on sponsorship, it considers specialist expertise, delegated authority, competing functional priorities and proportionate preparation. A hypothetical technology replacement illustrates how unsettled business choices can move into implementation. For executives and transformation leaders, the central implication is to make their respective commitments explicit and ensure that accountability is supported by workable decision authority and participation.

Keywords

Transformation Director; organisational readiness for change; executive ownership; executive sponsorship; transformation governance; enterprise transformation

The appointment leaves an important question open

I have spent more than twenty years working in organisational change and transformation. One assumption I have been reconsidering is that executives who approve a transformation also understand what delivering it will require of them. Recognising the need for change can create an impression of agreement that has not yet been tested against the work ahead.

An approved investment, an executive sponsor and an experienced Transformation Director give a programme an important foundation. They leave open whether the leadership team is prepared to examine existing practices, resolve competing priorities and take responsibility for changing how the business operates.

This matters particularly when transformation crosses functions. The director can organise the work and bring specialist judgement to it. Their appointment still needs to be accompanied by clarity about the decisions they can make, the decisions executives retain and how those responsibilities will work together.

Recognising the problem leaves business choices unresolved

Consider a hypothetical organisation replacing ageing technology. Its executives have discussed inconsistent processes and unreliable information for years. When the Transformation Director proposes examining current operations before designing the replacement, another review can feel frustrating. People believe they already understand what is wrong and want the investment to produce visible progress.

That frustration deserves attention. Existing analysis may be sufficient, and repeating it would consume time without improving a decision. Equally, agreement that processes are inconsistent does not establish which process the business should adopt, which variations are justified or who can approve an exception.

Poor data presents a similar issue. Acknowledging the problem leaves questions about definitions, ownership and correction responsibilities. Those questions require business judgement, including agreement between functions whose requirements may differ.

The director needs to establish what is already known and which decisions remain open. Executives need to be prepared to make those decisions. The relevant test is whether further examination changes the quality of the choice or makes an important dependency visible, rather than whether a methodology normally includes that activity.

Readiness concerns a particular change

Weiner (2009) offers a useful distinction in his theory of organisational readiness for change: a shared commitment to implementing a change and confidence in the organisation’s collective ability to carry it out. He also considers how people assess the work involved, the resources available and the circumstances of implementation.

This is a conceptual theory developed with healthcare implementation in view. It should not be presented as a validated test of whether an enterprise transformation will succeed. Its value here is to draw attention to what approval alone leaves uncertain: whether people are willing to undertake this particular change and believe they can implement it together.

My application of that distinction is to ask what sits behind executive agreement. Leaders may support the intended benefits while holding different expectations about the effort, the timing or the changes required within their functions. The leadership team’s confidence also cannot stand in for the views and practical knowledge of the people expected to do the work.

Specialist expertise needs a clear business explanation

A Transformation Director is appointed to bring expertise that complements the knowledge of functional executives. Their contribution includes understanding how activities connect, where a local decision may create consequences elsewhere and what the organisation will need to sustain a different way of operating.

In my view, that expertise deserves the same serious consideration given to finance, manufacturing or technology advice. It also carries a responsibility to explain the reasoning. A director recommending process analysis should be able to describe the decision it supports, the uncertainty it addresses and the consequences of proceeding without it.

Transformation practitioners do not always make that easy. Jargon, documents with no clear use and governance that adds delay can give executives reasonable grounds for scepticism. The response should be to demonstrate the value and proportionality of the work, including where a simpler approach would be adequate.

Executives should be able to challenge an approach without being characterised as resistant. The distinction I would examine is whether the challenge helps find a better way to resolve the issue or repeatedly leaves a necessary business decision untouched. Trust develops through useful judgement, clear explanations and a willingness to adjust.

Sponsorship connects the programme with the business

An executive sponsor can provide direction, secure attention and resources, and help resolve matters beyond the delivery team’s authority. Crawford et al. (2008), in their conference paper on project and programme sponsorship, examine the role through both governance and support. Their qualitative research also highlights how sponsorship varies with organisational and project context.

That research helps explain why sponsorship cannot be reduced to approving expenditure or receiving status reports. It does not establish a single executive structure for every enterprise transformation. The appropriate arrangement depends on the change, the organisation and the authority delegated to the people involved.

My concern arises when naming a sponsor becomes permission for other affected executives to disengage. A sponsor may be able to settle some cross-functional choices. They still need the knowledge, capacity and follow-through of the leaders whose operations will change.

Executive ownership, as I use the term here, means taking responsibility for the business decisions and operational changes within an agreed remit. It involves contributing to choices that cross that remit, including when the organisation’s preferred outcome creates inconvenience for a particular function.

The director’s mandate must match the decisions expected

The title Transformation Director does not, by itself, define authority. Some directors also hold operational responsibilities or receive substantial delegated decision rights. Others lead a programme while functional executives retain control of budgets, processes, people and performance expectations.

Both arrangements require clarity. A director who is accountable for an integrated outcome needs a workable route to decisions that sit outside their authority. For enterprise-wide work, I would want them involved in the executive discussions where priorities and competing demands are resolved, with the mandate and access appropriate to their role.

That does not mean referring every detail to the executive team. Routine choices should be made at the appropriate level. The difficulty is allowing an unresolved enterprise decision to circulate through delivery meetings because nobody present can settle it, while continuing to hold the director responsible for the resulting delay.

Functional leaders also need to support the consequences of decisions after a meeting ends. A decision to standardise a process has little operational meaning if local managers continue to require the previous approach. The transformation team can help explain and enable the transition; operational leadership must make the agreed expectations workable.

Executive commitments compete with existing demands

Participation has a practical cost. Leaders need time to examine options, involve people with relevant knowledge and resolve disagreements. Their teams may need capacity for design and testing alongside continuing operations. Endorsement without those commitments can leave a programme dependent on effort that has never been made available.

Performance expectations deserve examination too. An executive asked to support an enterprise improvement may also be judged on a functional target that discourages the necessary investment or temporary disruption. I would want those competing demands discussed openly, including who can authorise the trade-off.

This is a matter for judgement rather than a universal prescription to rewrite every incentive. Some existing arrangements will support the intended change. Where they conflict, leaders need to decide how the programme’s expectations fit with the responsibilities they already hold. Enthusiasm is unlikely to resolve an ongoing conflict over time, resources or authority.

Unresolved decisions can move into implementation

In the hypothetical technology replacement, a business rule left undecided may eventually be assumed during configuration. A disagreement about ownership may emerge during testing, when different teams expect different results. Correcting it could require revisiting work already completed.

This is a possible consequence of deferring a decision, rather than a claim that every unanswered question creates expensive rework. Some uncertainty is unavoidable, and implementation can produce information that was not available earlier. The task is to distinguish what can reasonably be learned later from what the next stage already depends on.

A proportionate approach can combine early decisions on consequential matters with controlled learning as the work progresses. Executives and the director need a shared understanding of which assumptions remain open, who owns them and what would prompt reconsideration. Readiness develops through the programme; it should not become an excuse for analysis without movement.

The executive team is part of the transformation

When an organisation appoints a Transformation Director, I would bring the executive team’s own commitments into the conversation. Which decisions will affected leaders retain? What participation can the programme rely on? How will they resolve conflicts between functional priorities and the intended enterprise outcome?

These questions do not replace the director’s delivery responsibilities. They make it possible to exercise those responsibilities within an organisation prepared to contribute its own leadership, knowledge and authority.

The appointment is a significant commitment to transformation. Its practical value depends on what follows: executives making the choices within their remit, supporting the changes in their operations and working with the director on the decisions that connect them. That is the readiness I would want to understand before treating an approved programme as evidence that the organisation is ready to transform.

References

Crawford, L., Cooke-Davies, T., Hobbs, J. B., Labuschagne, L., Remington, K. and Chen, P. (2008, 16 July). Governance and support in the sponsoring of projects and programs. Paper presented at PMI Research Conference: Defining the Future of Project Management, Warsaw, Poland. Project Management Institute. https://www.pmi.org/learning/library/governance-support-sponsoring-projects-programs-7107

Weiner, B. J. (2009). A theory of organizational readiness for change. Implementation Science, 4, Article 67. https://doi.org/10.1186/1748-5908-4-67

Publication and disclosure notes

Adapted from Dr Liz Wilson’s article “You’ve Appointed a Transformation Director. Are You Actually Ready to Transform?”, originally published on thedrliz.com. https://thedrliz.com/youve-appointed-a-transformation-director-are-you-actually-ready-to-transform/

The technology-replacement organisation and related implementation scenarios are hypothetical illustrations, not reported client cases or measured outcomes.

The author is Founder & Editor of Transformation Expert Insights and works professionally in behavioural and organisational transformation.

AI assistance: OpenAI ChatGPT assisted with adapting the original article, restructuring the argument, drafting wording and identifying and checking references. The author is responsible for the published content.

About the author

Dr Liz Wilson

Founder & Editor, Transformation Expert Insights

Dr Liz Wilson is a Behavioural Transformation Practitioner, behavioural scientist, author and keynote speaker. Her work connects behavioural science with the practical demands of organisational transformation, including leadership, governance, systems and everyday ways of working. She is interested in why people and organisations continue familiar practices despite understanding the case for change, and how the conditions surrounding work influence what becomes possible. She is Founder & Editor of Transformation Expert Insights, a professional publication bringing together research, commentary and practitioner perspectives on business and enterprise transformation.

Professional website: https://thedrliz.com/

Back to top ↑Contact the editor